My NOTP for them: Madoka if the new season or movies turns Homura into Chikane. But if that happened, I'd ragequit the series, so that won't really matter. :P
My OTF (One True Friendship) for them: Toadette. She can be "Secret Friends" with Wario, so befriending the devil isn't out of question.
My OTP for them: Madoka
My second choice pairing for them: Hitomi. COME AT ME FANDOM
My fluffy pairing for them: Madoka
My angsty pairing for them: Madoka again. It's not really angsty with Sayaka so much as it is kismesis.
My favorite poly ship for them: Holy Quintet OT5~
My weirdest pairing for them: The Batter from OFF. It surprisingly fits well. :o